The Hindu : Opinion / Lead : How not to tackle the black economy in India

The Hindu : Opinion / Lead : How not to tackle the black economy in India

Technically, we know how to check the black economy but the problem is political. More studies or committees and treaties with foreign governments are only to stall action.

Another Joint Parliamentary Committee has been announced. The government has been trying to create an impression of being proactive with regard to tackling the black economy. The President's address and the speech by Sonia Gandhi in January mentioned the need to curb it. The Prime Minister at various fora, while expressing helplessness, has emphasised action. The Supreme Court has been applying pressure to tackle black savings spirited out of the country and for unearthing wrongdoings in cases of corruption like the 2G spectrum allocation case. Home Minister P. Chidambaram admitted in Davos that in road construction, 50 per cent of the funds are misappropriated. He has stated that there is deficit in governance and ethical functioning of government and the Prime Minister has endorsed this. Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee has announced studies into different aspects of the black economy and a Group of Ministers has been set up to tackle the problem. Talks are on for Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA) with various countries — supposedly to unearth wealth kept abroad by Indians.

Is the government finally serious about bringing back the black funds stashed away abroad, variously estimated to be between $ 462 billion and several trillions of dollars? These figures seem credible when one considers the scale of the current scams (tens of billions of dollars) and the case of Hasan Ali where the tax demand runs into billions of dollars. The CD containing names of Indians with bank accounts in the LTG bank which the Indian government accepted in March 2009, a year-and-a-half after it was offered by the German government, has added to the pressure on the government. There are 77 tax havens where illegal funds are stashed away; Switzerland is only the biggest and best known.

The government's actions seem to be in direct proportion to the public pressure on it as exposes come in thick and fast. The problem is not new, so what explains the earlier inaction? Consider Bofors or the 2G spectrum case. Initially there has been denial and then minimal action, allowing the culprits time to escape (as in Hasan Ali's case where the money has disappeared). Rs.35 lakh crore in black income is generated annually and about 10 per cent of it goes abroad. The capital lost through this route is greater than annual net foreign investment, yet action is minimal.

The government pleads that tax havens do not reveal names unless criminality is established and that the Swiss government does not treat tax evasion as a crime. The moot point is why did the Swiss government announce the immediate freezing of Hosni Mubarak's assets without the Egyptian government giving any evidence of criminality? Further, why did UBS agree first to give the names of 250 U.S. citizens and then another 4,500 names to the U.S. tax authorities in 2007-08 without any criminality being individually established? In the Hasan Ali case, the Swiss government has said that it has not been given the information required. Similarly, in Ottavio Quattrocchi's case, the Indian government has twice lost in foreign courts because the case has not been properly established. In 1992, Madhavsinh Solanki, then Minister of External Affairs, passed on a chit to a Swiss Minister apparently to slow down the Bofors case but the Narasimha Rao government quietly buried the embarrassment by accepting his resignation. The few cases of corruption initiated against the high and mighty are apparently spoilt or not pursued.

Given this history, will there be seriousness this time or will the government wait out the storm? In the last 60 years, dozens of committees have studied various aspects of the black economy and given thousands of suggestions. Hundreds of these suggestions have been implemented but the size of the black economy has grown exponentially. The Wanchoo Committee report bulges with suggestions. Since 1971, when the highest tax rate was 97.5 per cent, tax rates have fallen but the black economy has grown from 7 per cent to 50 per cent of GDP. Controls and regulations have been drastically eliminated after 1991 but the size of black economy continues to rise. The causes of black income generation lie elsewhere. The recent rise in corporate tax collection is a reflection of rising disparity and not better compliance.

Plugging loopholes has only made the laws more complex, as in the case of taxation. The ingenuity of the corrupt thwarts the enforcement agencies by either devising newer ways of circumventing the law or simply bribing the officials. In India, laws on paper and in practice differ because of the ‘Triad' of the corrupt business class, the political class, and the executive (see the article “Honesty is indivisible,” The Hindu, January 29, 2011) who bend rules to their advantage. The philosophy is: if I am in power, I can bend rules for the favoured.

In brief, technically we know what needs to be done to check the black economy — but the problem is political. The top echelons of the leadership are the prime drivers of the black economy. They do not wish to forgo the massive illegal profits they generate. So how can the political will be generated?

A voluntary disclosure scheme to bring back black savings stashed away abroad for ‘development' is being considered. Wasn't the Mauritius route created to allow round tripping of funds? It has accelerated black income generation by facilitating it. A National Security Adviser alerted the nation to terror funds entering the stock markets to destabilise the financial markets. The Wanchoo Committee argued that this kind of scheme makes honest people dishonest. A report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India on the 1997 voluntary disclosure scheme pointed out that the same people who declared their black incomes earlier took advantage of the 1997 scheme — becoming habitual tax offenders.

Some argue that elections underlie black income generation and corruption. Presently, when a Lok Sabha constituency sees the expenditure of crores of rupees per serious candidate, state funding will make little difference. At best, it can be to the tune of the allowed election expenditure of Rs.25 lakh — just a few per cent of the actual expenditure by most candidates. Further, what is spent on the national elections officially and unofficially is not even 1 per cent of GDP for that year; so this cannot be the cause of black incomes. It is the black economy that works to subvert the elections. Our present day legislators are largely the representatives of the monied and the powerful and not of the people; so they need to keep the public confused to win elections. They resort to vote bank politics and bribing voters and that is what makes elections costly. Genuine democracy would not be expensive. Today, we have formal democracy with weak content.

In this background, it is clear that the government's actions against corruption will be in proportion to the public outrage and that too the minimum necessary. It is likely that there will be pretence while the real culprits go scot-free. Setting up a committee is to buy time and to stall questions on the subject since the government can claim it is waiting for the report. Later, it can buy time by pretending to look into the recommendations or bury an inconvenient report (like the Vora Committee report).

The Supreme Court is going after the names of those spiriting away money abroad but not after the generation of the funds. The black incomes generated in the country are ten times the size of what is siphoned out. In the liberalised environment, those with black money stashed away abroad can turn into non-residents overnight and escape prosecution in India. This is perhaps the reason the Indian government is unable to proceed against the eight entities named in the Liechtenstein disc. For the rest, little money may be left in their accounts, given the inordinate delays. Taxation treaties being entered into by the government with other governments are all about legal incomes traceable to known individuals. But black incomes are typically parked via shell companies and in benami accounts.

What is needed is serious investigation and prosecution in the country that will also expose the money siphoned off abroad. The government functionaries generating black incomes personally indulge in various illegalities such as using hawala. So, in principle, there is private knowledge but not public information to stop these activities. The help of foreign governments is hardly needed in this matter. Intelligence agencies provide the leadership with information through tapping and so on, which can be mined instead of being used for political blackmail. The prosecution agencies deliberately spoil cases for political reasons. If prosecution is not possible in India, how can the case be made in foreign lands for booking the culprits?

In brief, the policy pronouncements are delaying and diversionary tactics to allow those generating black incomes to escape via shell companies and benami accounts. There were limited gains from earlier JPCs but will this time be different? It will be only if there is political will and action — and not more studies or treaties with foreign governments.

(The author is Chairperson of the Centre for Economic Studies and Planning, School of Social Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi. He is the author of The Black Economy in India, Penguin India, 2002. He can be reached at arunkumar1000@hotmail.com.)

Keywords: Black money, illegal funds, corrupt politicians, UPA government, Swiss banks, Sonia Gandhi, Hasan Ali, GDP growth, Indian economy
Ads by Google

Save Tax
India First Insurance plans with Tax Benefits under Section 80C
www.indiafirst-lifeinsurance.com
Related
NEWS
Law of the land will punish wrongdoers: Manmohan
Confiscate black money, says CPI
Sharing information on black money with India: Mauritius
LINKS
26th main
TOPICS
crime, law and justice

Comments:
At the end of the day it boils down to the social culture and responsibility of the people. You can never stop those who want to do bad things until you make them not want to do it. Case in example- financial structure in usa. dedicatedly corrosive behaviour will always find loopholes in any system.
from: Sri
Posted on: Feb 25, 2011 at 23:17 IST

There has to be sweeping reforms that will mandate: Limits on the size of political parties and the campaign funds; Qualifying criteria for being a legislator, including education. Full disclosures of wealth (not excluding benamis) Severe and exemplary punishments for lying or falsifying records Tax payers should have a bigger and better say in the voting process, simply mass numbers alone should be the consideration. There has to be auditing of all current politicians of their assets with a goal to establish a legal trail for the same. There has to be severe exemplary punishment for cheats and thieves. The problem is the concept of reservation has been hijacked to strengthen party positions by packing cadres and supporters in all our institutions. So how will there be reforms? Sadly these scams will be nothing more than deja vu!
from: P.S. Swaminathan
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 00:33 IST

The action required of the readers is clear. Pressure the government to act against corruption and other ills. And, participate in people-led movements such as India Against Corruption (http://www.indiaagainstcorruption.org). Our government and politicians are thick-skinned. They need to be pushed before they act, albeit unwillingly.
from: K Palaka
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 02:37 IST

Finance Minister told parliament that he cannot disclose the names of persons who have black money stashed away abroad until a case agaonst them is filed in a court. How then is A.Raja, a former minister, being arraigned even before a case is filed against him? Clearly there are other considertions behind what Mr.Mukherjee told parliament! By the way, why the government and the opposition are talking only about 'bringing back' black money and punishing those who are guilty and not about taking steps to stop the generation of black money?
from: K.Vijayakumar
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 06:37 IST

Political corruption is alarming. crony capitalism is the issue. In USA every thing is privatized. govt do only few services. They make sure those few are delivered with highest quality. The govt never involves with private companies how they operate. If they do any wrong, that's it; they have to file bankruptsy, and owner would be in jail for 20 years.
from: Venu
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 07:06 IST

Now it is quite obvious that India is a corruption based economy.Black money is not going to make a big difference in our economy anyway.But we have to practice our democracy again and again to detain the culprits. We are losing our image in world market, but any significant impact upon our economy has not been seen yet.We don't have much time to recover our image.
from: Pradeep Mishra
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 09:01 IST

This article is very interesting. What is said is right -"the government's actions against corruption will be in proportion to the public outrage and that too the minimum necessary". There should be thorough, quick and fair investigation by authorities. Politicians should not use this investigation to even the scores against their rivals rather punish the culprits. Supreme Court should also find ways to unearth how black money is generated.
from: Namadev
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 09:53 IST

Black money is becoming like a black dream for India.Recent exposure by the above said article makes it clear that earlier known biggest source of black money in the economy is probably not the elections. Rather shamefully it seems that almost every nook and corner of the economy is efficiently generating black money-rightly to be called as parallel economy. This situation has created a kind of dilemma in the hearts and minds of Govt. That even if we plan to clean it up, the question is from where to start..? Further contradiction between the terms spirituality and immorality has highlighted that the concept of a devout person and being honest are two different ones.Spirituality should be replaced by a more acceptable term that is 'accountability' as that can be enforced legally.Leaving aside the Utopian talks the only left way is to tax that black money and spend that on building social infrastructure primarily-as that is the most pragmatic way to clean the sins committed by the society & against the society.
from: shaleen
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 10:43 IST

The general content of the article is okay. but the author has made a blatant attempt to hide the corruption of the BJP era and to high light the scandals of the Congress era. This is a blatant attempt to tarnish the image of UPA Goverment and genuine concern to find the solution to the menace of black money. I am surprised that author did not know the answer to the most simplest problem 'why did Swiss authorities freeze the accounts of Hosni Mubarak or give the names of American tax evaders - it is because the Americans are powerful. Even a boy knows the reason.
from: Alexmon
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 11:35 IST

What is written in the middle of the article, is actully the bottom line- "The top echelons of the leadership are the prime drivers of the black economy. They do not wish to forgo the massive illegal profits they generate/" But this article gives a sense of negative feel to us, "commmon Indian" . It is much too obvious that black money, corruption, nepotism, crony capitalism etc all have political basis. I think the futher path on which our nation is moving is bifurcating point of time... either our politician will understand the meaning of latin phase "momento mori" which seems highly unlikey or the masses will go the Egypt way (this too is unlikely considering the fractions and subset with different priorities in our society)!! but this is fast becoming more probable with the indifferent and shameless attitude of our leaders.
from: Rajeev Tewari
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 13:05 IST

"Genuine democracy would not be expensive" - what a powerful and concise statement. I have lived in some European countries and have witnessed this, particularly the elections. It clearly shows one thing if not others - which is how "civilised" election procedures are! I seriously doubt if we will ever get to see such a day in democratic India! One thing which I would attribute this to is - education and access to information. Majority of Indians fail to see the bigger picture as intended by politicians. But that wont last long...
from: Siva
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 14:29 IST

Thanks for such a great article. We are working in Private sector. We have to work more than 12 hours and most of the time no weekends, more targets and lot of pressure, than we earn some money and 50% of that goes in tax and with rest we keep paying the interest of home loans and if possible buy a bike. Now we pay Rs1 Lakh per year as direct income tax and 1 lakh more on other tax. What will happen to us if company fires us today? Can we ask Govt to help us during such crises. Govt is taking away our hard earned money where as our Job is not secure as compared to people working in Govt sector. So i think Govt should take responsibility of our children schooling, our home loan etc, becuase we paid tax during the time when we were earning. This happened to my friend, he paid lot of tax during the time he was earning good in marketing as incentive, he was working day and night. In 2009 he lost job and after that he is on road. So is it not govt responsibility to look after his children and all, for last 10 year he was paying tax and when he is fired govt has nothing for him.
from: Dinesh
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 15:06 IST

The political leaders have brought shame to the country by allowing such levels of corruption and passively supporting the same. It is very important to make a new beginning by actually prosecuting the wrong doers. That should serve as a warning bell to the others in line. An Egypt-like rising does not seem impossible and might bring the political class to justice.
from: Rajiv Suresh
Posted on: Feb 26, 2011 at 15:42 IST